Mottavik

Guide

How to value a donor car and track payback

A donor car has paid back once sales of its parts return the purchase price, and what to pay for the next one comes from your own paid-back cars of the same model.

This guide is for yard owners who buy cars for parts. It covers what to record at purchase, how to run a dismantle plan, how to count revenue and payback, and how to set a purchase ceiling from your own numbers. It works the same for a small yard and a large auto dismantler.

Purchase price: where it starts

Payback is measured against one number: what the car cost. Record it on the day you buy, not “later”. Decide once whether towing or delivery counts as part of the price, and do the same for every car. Otherwise you cannot compare one car with another.

What to record on the vehicle card

  • VIN, make, model and year.
  • Purchase price and currency.
  • Purchase date: the payback clock starts here.
  • Condition: what is damaged, what is intact, whether the engine runs.

How Mottavik does it

The vehicle card holds the purchase price. A VIN fills in the make, and for cars built for the US market also the model, year, engine, transmission and drive. For other cars you pick the model and generation from the catalog: 391 makes, 4,986 models, 10,269 generations. Currencies: UAH, USD, EUR and GBP.

Dismantle plan: what to pull

Before you undo the first bolt, write down the parts you plan to sell. Not everything is worth pulling. A part that sits for years costs labor to remove, shelf space, and money tied up in the donor.

How to build the plan

  1. Look at what sold from this model before, and how fast.
  2. Pull the parts that sell fast for this model first.
  3. Mark every line: to remove, taken off, or skipped.
  4. A skipped part is a decision, not forgotten work. Write down why: broken, does not sell, no space.

Count labor too. If a part takes two hours to pull and sells for less than those two hours of pay, skip it. That way the plan protects your payroll, not just your shelves.

How Mottavik does it

The plan comes from a template for the model and generation, and it takes the engine and transmission into account. A part is pre-ticked when it was taken off at least half of the template's cars. Lines have three states: To remove, Taken off, Skipped. Templates are shared across companies and anonymous: no prices, photos, labels or company names go into them.

Revenue part by part

You cannot measure payback if a part sale is not linked to its donor. So every part on record points to the car it came from. When the part sells, its price is added to that car's revenue.

A return lowers revenue. A written-off part adds nothing but stays in the history. That way a car's revenue is the money that actually stayed in the till, not the sum of receipts.

How Mottavik does it

The vehicle card shows the purchase price, revenue, payback percentage, and the value of parts still on the shelves. You set the price of each part: Mottavik does not suggest it automatically.

Payback over time

Payback percentage is revenue divided by purchase price. 100% means the car has returned the money you put in. Everything above that goes toward profit.

Example: a donor car bought for $3,000
PeriodRevenue to datePayback
First 30 days$1,20040%
By day 90$2,55085%
By day 180$3,300110%
After day 180$3,450115%

In this example the car paid back between day 90 and day 180. The first weeks bring in the most money, because the fast-moving parts go right away. Then sales slow down, and the rest of the parts hold the shelves. The figures are made up; yours will differ.

Median payback

One car tells you little. Look at the median: how many days a typical car in your yard takes to pay back. The median beats the average, because one car that hangs on for a year does not skew the picture.

How Mottavik does it

Analytics shows median payback and unrecovered cash: how much is still tied up in cars that have not paid back. The dashboard lists the cars awaiting payback. Periods: 7, 30 and 90 days, month, quarter and year to date. Money figures are visible only to people with the analytics right.

Inventory aging: 0–30, 30–90, 90–180, 180+

The donor money that has not come back is sitting in parts on the shelf. To see where it is stuck, split your stock by age: how many days each part has been in the warehouse.

Four age buckets
Age, daysWhat it isWhat to do
0–30Fresh parts.Nothing. They are still selling.
30–90Normal stock.Check that each part has photos and a manufacturer's number.
90–180Slow movers.Review the price and the description.
180+Dead stock.Decide: lower the price, sell as a lot, or write it off.

If the 180+ bucket holds many parts from one model, change the dismantle plan. Skip those parts on the next donor of that model.

How Mottavik does it

The Inventory section of analytics shows part aging in the same buckets: 0–30, 30–90, 90–180 and over 180 days. Parts older than 180 days show up separately as dead stock.

What to pay for the next donor car

The most expensive mistake a yard makes is overpaying for a car. The answer to what to pay is already in your data: the revenue from cars of the same model that have paid back.

P25, P50 and P75 in plain words

Take all paid-back cars of one model and line them up by revenue, from lowest to highest. A percentile shows where a figure sits in that line.

What each mark means
MarkWhat it meansHow to use it
P25A quarter of the cars brought in less than this.A cautious estimate. Use it for cars in unknown condition.
P50Half the cars brought in less, half brought in more.Typical revenue from this model.
P75Only a quarter of the cars brought in more.The best realistic case. Do not pay as if you will get it.

From revenue to ceiling is one step: subtract the profit you want. Say the model's P50 is $4,500 and you want to make at least a third. Then do not pay more than $3,000 for a car in typical condition. For a car in unknown condition, start from P25.

If you have fewer than three paid-back cars of a model, percentiles mean nothing. Look at similar models instead and buy with care.

Part prices move with the market. Check the ceiling before every purchase, not once a year.

How Mottavik does it

The purchase ceiling is calculated for each model from the revenue of your own paid-back cars: P25, P50 and P75. It needs at least three such cars. These are your numbers, not a market average.

Questions

Should towing count toward the donor's price?

What matters is doing it the same way for every car. If you sometimes add towing and sometimes not, payback across cars cannot be compared. The simplest rule: purchase price plus delivery to the yard.

When does a car count as paid back?

When revenue from its parts, minus returns, reaches the purchase price, which is 100%. Parts still on the shelf are possible money, not payback.

What if a model is new to my yard?

You have no paid-back cars of that model yet, so there is no ceiling either. Buy the first car with care, follow the dismantle plan and run every sale through the system. After three paid-back cars you will have a ceiling of your own.

Want to see this in your yard?

We will show you on a demo how it works with your own data.

Request access